Data mining-based detection of the clinical effect on motion style acupuncture therapy combined with conventional acupuncture therapy in chronic neck pain

1.Introduction

Cervical spondylosis [1, 2] is a series of syndromes caused by chronic strain or acute injury and may manifest as neck pain, stiffness, dizziness, numbness in arms and weakness in legs. As the most common symptom of cervical spondylosis, neck pain (NP) was ranked the fourth leading cause of disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) globally in 2017 [3, 4], and the global incidence of neck pain was calculated to be 16.2% in 2018 [5]. Although the conventional acupuncture therapy (CAT) is widely used in neck pain treatment for the obvious instant effect, studies [6, 7] show that the recurrence rate of neck pain keeps high due to the poor maintenance effect of CAT. On the other hand, several studies [8, 9, 10] considered that CAT combined with motion style acupuncture therapy (MSAT) has better efficacy, especially when pain is caused by the skeletal motor system. Therefore, both treatments are widely applied in the clinic.

However, whether the treatment is suitable for the patient should be taken into consideration. The application of CAT and MSAT has not been standardized yet. Most of the acupuncturists choose the treatment by clinical symptom and medical history, which leads to the huge difference in clinical effect.

In fact, there are many methods to evaluate the severity of neck pain, and many of them can be quantified, among which we choose the pain pressure threshold (PPT) and the MOS item short from health survey (SF-36) as reference to discuss the relationship between them and the clinical effect.

To reduce statistical bias, we take the further data mining method on the basis of traditional statistics. In brief, this study aims to discuss the indications for CAT and MSAT combined with CAT in neck pain patients through data mining method, so that the result can give advice to clinical treatment for different kind of neck pain patients.

2.Methods

2.1Trial design

The trial is designed as an assessor-blinded RCT to confirm whether the effect of CAT combined with MSAT is better than CAT. Seventy-six participants with chronic neck pain will be randomly assigned into intervention group and control group with the ratio of 1:1. The process of the trial is detailed in Fig. 1 and Table 1.

Table 1

Time to visit and data collection

Study period
	Visit 1	Visit 2	Visit 3	Visit 4	Visit 5
Time node	-7 ∼ 0 day	One-time treatment	One-course treatment	Two-course treatment	One-month follow-up
Informed consent	∙
Randomization	∙
General information	∙
Medical history	∙
Imaging examination	∙
Assessment	∙
PE	∙	∙	∙	∙	∙
PPT	∙	∙	∙	∙	∙
SF-36	∙			∙	∙
Safety observation		∙	∙	∙	∙
Adverse event record		∙	∙	∙	∙
Obedience evaluation		∙	∙	∙	∙
Combined treatment records		∙	∙	∙	∙

*If the subjects are directly enrolled at the first visit, i.e., visit 1 and visit 2 events coincide, visit 2 index will be taken as the baseline. *PE, physical examination; PPT, pain pressure threshold; SF-36, the MOS item short from health survey.

Figure 1.

Flowchart of the study.

This trial is designed in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and has been approved by the ethics committee of Shanghai Shuguang Hospital (Permission number: 2018-580-09-01). The trial has been registered at the Chinese Clinical Trial Registry (no. ChiCTR1900025413). Informed consent form of all participants will be obtained before enrollment after informing them about the outline and detail of the trial.

2.3Interventions

The treatments were taken in Acupuncture and Moxibustion Department of Shanghai Shuguang Hospital by acupuncturists with more than 5 years clinical experience. In order to minimize the environment bias and emotion effect, all treatments were provided at afternoon in the same consulting room.

2.3.1Control group: CAT

The control group accepted CAT at local acupoints of neck according to textbook named Acupuncture and Moxibustion [11], including Cervical Jiaji (EXB2), Fengchi (GB20), Tianzhu (BL10), Jianjin (GB21), Tianzong (SI11) and Ashi points (Table 2 and Fig. 2). The treatment took twice a week for 5 weeks with a total of 2 courses. The single-use stainless steel needle (0.25 × 40 mm) (Suzhou Medical Products Factory Co., Ltd. Suzhou 215005, China) was used and Deqi sensation (a sensation of sour, numbness or distension) was achieved during process. Needle was retained for 20 mins and then withdrew quickly. Patients were required to exercise their neck in appropriate range after treatment.

Table 2

Acupoint locations and standards used for locating acupoints used in this trial*

Acupoints	Locations	For treatment	For measurement
GB20s	In the anterior region of the neck, inferior to the occipital bone, in the depression between the origins of sternocleidomastoid and the trapezius muscles.	√
BL10s	In the posterior region of the neck, at the same level of the superior border of the spinous process of the second cervical vertebra (C2), in the depression lateral to the trapezius muscles.	√
EX-B2s	In the posterior region of the neck, 0.5 B-cun bilateral to the posterior median line, under the spinous process, between the first cervical vertebrae and the seventh cervical vertebrae.	The second, fourth and sixth cervical vertebrae level of both sides.	The fourth and sixth cervical vertebrae level of both sides.
SI11s	In the scapular region, in the depression between the upper one third and the lower two thirds of the line connecting the midpoint of the spine of the scapula with the inferior angle of the scapula.	√
GB21s	In the posterior region of the neck, at the midpoint of the line connecting the spinous process of the seventh cervical vertebra (C7) with the lateral end of the acromion.	√
SI3s	On the dorsum of the hand, in the depression proximal to the ulnar side of the fifth metacarpophalangeal joint, at the border between the red and white flesh.	√

*Reference: WHO standard acupuncture point locations in the Western Pacific Region 2008. B-cun, proportional bone (skeletal) cun.

Figure 2.

Location of acupoints.

2.3.2Intervention group: CAT combined with MSAT

The treatment interval and times of intervention group were the same as that of the control group. In addition to CAT same as the control group, MSAT at Houxi (SI3) of painful side was further applied. Patients were required to exercise their neck up and down, left and right slowly during needling, while the range of exercise was up to the tolerate of pain. The whole process of MSAT was sustained for 5 times exercise cycle. Sustained-release or prophylactic analgesics were not allowed.

2.5Outcomes

2.5.1Pain pressure threshold

PPT measurement has been widely used in relatively objective pain intensity qualification [12, 13]. Four fixed points (Fig. 3), including EX-B2s at the fourth and the sixth cervical vertebra on both sides, have been selected for measurement, and the value of pressure at each point will be shown clearly on the digital screen of measuring apparatus (Force One FDIX Multi-capacity Digital Force Gage).

Figure 3.

Location of measurement points.

2.5.2Quality of life

SF-36 [14] is a health-related questionnaire in eight dimensions, including Role-Emotional (RE), Role-Physical (RP), Physical Functioning (PF), Social Functioning (SF), General Health (GH), Bodily Pain (BP), Vitality (VT) and Mental Health (MH), which may provide a more comprehensive reference for patients’ life quality.

3.Analysis

4.Result

4.2GRA in Acupuncture effect of different time points

GRA showed that every acupoint had different characteristic in both group at four time nodes (Table 4). Take C⁢4L as example. In intervention group, the effect was better after one-time treatment (correlation of 0.68), then the correlation got smaller after one-course treatment (correlation of 0.10) and the improvement got slower after two-course treatment (correlation of 0.14), however, the correlation gradually increased after one-month follow-up (correlation of 0.18). In control group, the effect was general after one-time treatment (correlation of 0.44), while it improved after one-course treatment (correlation of 0.55) and the correlation gradually got smaller after two-course treatment and one-month follow-up (correlation of 0.55 and 0.26). The correlation of other acupoints are shown in Figs 4 and 5.

Figure 4.

Correlation of PPT at C4.

Through the results of data mining in intervention group, the GRA shows that as the instant effect of acupuncture is the basement of long-term effect, the best effect appears after one-time treatment in C⁢4L, C⁢4R and C⁢6L, while it appears after one-course treatment in C⁢6R. In control group, the best effect appears after one-course treatment in C⁢4L, and appears after one-time treatment in another three acupoints. After one-month follow-up, the relational coefficient of 4 acupoints are similar or higher than that after two-course treatment in intervention group, while in control group only the relational coefficient of C⁢6L is higher than that after two-course treatment, the other three acupoints all show downward trend.

4.3The influence of Health status before treatment on PPT by mutual information method based on Shannon entropy

Mining the correlation between SF-36 and PPT changes of C⁢4L, C⁢4R, C⁢6L, C⁢6R before and after treatment by mutual information method based on Shannon entropy can describe the non-liner relationship between them and certain the health assessment items before treatment that play an important role in the effect of acupuncture treatment [19].

Set the eight items in SF-36 as X, the PPT changes of C⁢4L, C⁢4R, C⁢6L, C⁢6R before and after treatment as Y. The relationship between them is shown in Table 5.

Table 5

Correlation analysis of Shannon entropy between SF-36 and PPT before treatment

		PF	RP	BP	GH	VT	SF	RE	MH
Rank of correlation	Intervention group	0.03	0.02	0.01	0.00	0.01	0.02	0.03	0.00
		2	4	6	7	5	3	1	8
	Control group	0.00	0.00	0.00	0.03	0.00	0.01	0.01	0.00
		6	8	7	1	4	3	2	5

Figure 5.

Correlation of PPT at C6.

The result showed that the “correlation coefficients” of the relevant items in the SF-36 and the PPT of four acupoints in the intervention group are RE, PF, SF, RP, VT, BP, GH, MH (ranked from strong to weak), which meant the main influencing factors of intervention group are RE, PF and SF, while those in control group are GH, RE and SF, which means the difference of main influencing factors between intervention group and control group is PF and GH. Therefore, MSAT combined with CAT is more objective to improve PF, and CAT is more universal to improve GH.

5.Discussion

In recent years, the incidence of cervical spondylosis continuously rises for the popularity of electronic products and the maintenance of long-term forward neck posture [20, 21]. In this study, by measuring the raw data of PPT and SF-36 before and after MSAT combined with CAT and CAT treatment, data mining technology is used to deeply explore the implicit correlation between the two and different acupuncture treatments, as well as their clinical effects. The inherent regularity characteristics of the data and symptoms provide technical support for in-depth exploration of the clinical efficacy of different acupuncture treatments of neck pain.

SF and RE are the common main factors in both groups that influence PPT. RE refers to the limitation of function due to own emotional problems. SF represents the impact of physiological and psychological problems on the quantity and quality of social activities and is an indicator to evaluate the effect of health on social activities [14]. Neck pain belongs to deep body pain and usually causes by the damage of soft tissue and muscle. When deep pain occurs, the skeletal muscle near the painful region contracts reflectively and leads to local tissue ischemia, which further aggravates the pain [22]. Patients with body pain may have negative explanations for pain, which in turn may lead to pain physiology, cognition and fear avoidance reactions [23]. Fear and negative perception of pain may lead to escape, cause disability and painful movement, and form a negative pain cycle [24]. In severe cases, it can further affect the patient’s psychological and social activities [25]. The results shows that the analgesic effect of acupuncture in the treatment of neck pain has greatly improved the patient’s emotional function and social function. If the patient feels less pain and gains more mobility through encouragement and acupuncture therapy, a positive cycle can be created and the treatment effect can be improved [26]. Modern research [27, 28, 29] believes that acupuncture mainly exerts analgesic effects by inhibiting the pain transmission pathway or regulating the release of cytokines, and due to its remarkable and time-dependent analgesic effect, the analgesic effect of acupuncture has been widely used in treatment of various diseases.

In addition to the common factors, PF and GH are the main difference between two groups. PF, as one of the three main factors in intervention group, is mainly used to assess whether the health condition has affected the physiological activities of the patient [14]. MSAT is a therapy requires the active or passive movement cooperation of patient during the acupuncturist’s manipulation at specific points. The possible mechanism of MSAT [30, 31] lies in relieving muscle spasm, accelerating blood circulation and enhancing pain threshold. When the patient exercises, the mechanical conditions of the acupoints and their surroundings will change [32]. In the dynamic treatment process, from the analysis of the sensitization of the acupoints, the acupuncture points will have the effect of “force sensitivity, pressure sensitivity, and pain sensitivity” [33]. The acupuncture points are stimulated, and the curative effect is correspondingly improved. On the other side, the transmission of central motion information can inhibit the input of somatic pain information, thus MSAT can achieve a significant analgesic effect [34]. In brief, MSAT can not only improve the restricted activities of neck, but also have an analgesic effect. Therefore, MSAT has a better effect on patients with PF scores mild to moderate decline before treatment.

To patients in control group, CAT has better effect in patients scored among 56.0862 to 66.0948 in GH before treatment. GH represents an individual’s evaluation of their own health status and development trends [14]. The data interval represents that patients believe that they are in good health and can maintain that level of health in the future. The number of patients with cervical spondylosis who have negative emotions is much higher than that of normal people, which may be related to chronic neck pain that affects the quality of life. Research [35] shows that patients with higher psychological scores and clear awareness of their own health status may have relatively better effects. Therefore, patients in high GH can better relief their neck pain after treatment. In other words, people with low GH score may be more suitable for other treatments, such as moxibustion, ironing, and Chinese medicine.

To sum up, patients with low role-emotional and social functioning are suitable for acupuncture treatment, among which patients with mild to moderate decline in physical functioning are more appropriate for MSAT combined with CAT, while patients with high general health may have better effect by CAT.

6.Conclusion

The quality of life can be comprehensively assessed before neck pain patients have relative treatment. Acupuncture can be used for patients with good emotional function and social function scores; among them, patients with good general health can be treated with conventional acupuncture therapy, and patients with mild to moderate decline in physiological function can choose motion style acupuncture therapy combined with conventional acupuncture therapy. It is hoped that through the data mining, certain ideas can be provided for the application of acupuncture clinical syndrome differentiation treatment, so as to achieve the purpose of adapting measures to individual conditions and improving curative effects.

This study is the first attempt in neck pain treatment which try to formulate related acupuncture treatments due to the objective index and subjective symptom before treatment. The selection of scale may be incomplete and due to the specialization of acupuncture manipulation, double-blind is hard to be performed, however assessor-blind is designed to decrease bias and the study may provide new ideas in the choice of acupuncture methods in different type of neck pain patients. Further studies can be designed to discuss indications of different acupuncture therapies, so that the clinical effect of acupuncture will be further improved.

Author contributions

Ruo-yun Lyu, Zong-lin Wen, Ming Gao and Bo Wang developed and designed the study. Ruo-yun Lyu and Zong-lin Wen wrote the manuscript. Wen-chao Tang, Xu-ming Yang, Jun-ling Wen and Ming Gao reviewed the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Data availability

All data generated and analyzed in the study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.