PRDM1 rs2185379, unlike BRCA1, is not a prognostic marker in patients with advanced ovarian cancer

1.Introduction

Ovarian cancer (OC) is mostly diagnosed in advanced stages (70%), leading to a high incidence-to-mortality rate. Although patients with advanced OC achieve remission with maximum debulking surgery and chemotherapy, recurrence, usually incurable, often occurs within 3 years and the 5-year survival of late-stage OC is below 30% [1]. Nevertheless, some OC patients achieve long-term disease-free survival despite the diagnosis at advanced stage. Thus, attempts are being made to identify further prognostic markers of long-term survival. Recently, the polymorphism rs2185379 in PRDM1 has been associated with long-term recurrence-free survival in Japanese advanced OC patients and, based on the mouse model, heterozygous rs2185379 was suggested to induce initial differentiation of T lymphocytes in antitumor immune response [2]. However, the precise impact of rs2185379 on protein function or possible linkage to another variant with prognostic significance is unknown. The minor allele frequency of rs2185379 in GnomAD varies between populations from 2% in Latino America to 3.1% in European non-Finnish, 5.9% in East Asian and 7% in African American.

The PRDM1 (positive regulatory domain zinc finger protein 1; OMIM*603423) codes for the BLIMP1 (B lymphocyte-induced maturation protein 1) transcription factor that is involved in the regulation of antitumor immunity. It was recently shown that BLIMP1 enhances transcription of USP22 deubiquitinating enzyme leading to decreased degradation of SPI1 transcription factor and subsequent enhanced expression of programmed death ligand 1 (PD-L1), which leads to infiltrated CD8+ T cell exhaustion and memory responses [3]. BLIMP1 was shown to play a role in the development of malignant lymphoma, leukemia, and some non-haematopoietic cancers, including breast and colorectal cancer, hepatocellular carcinoma, or glioma as reviewed in [4]. In particular, decreased expression of PRDM1 correlates with a poor prognosis in lung cancer [5]. However, little is known about the role of PRDM1 in ovarian cancer. Zhang et al. suggested that tumour-infiltrating T lymphocytes can improve the long-term outcome of patients with advanced OC [6].

In this work, we explored the association of heterozygous rs2185379 PRDM1 variant with long-term survival of advanced OC and compared the effect of rs2185379 with selected clinicopathological and genetic factors influencing the prognosis of OC patients.

2.Methods

3.Results

We performed genotyping of 545 well-characterized advanced-stage OC patients that were previously tested for OC cancer predisposition [7]. We identified 37 (6.8%) OC patients heterozygous for rs2185379 and no homozygote of the alternative allele (consistent with Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium).

Figure 1.

The effect of monitored variables on survival of patients diagnosed with advanced OC. Figure 1 shows univariate survival analysis of the PRDM1 rs2185379 status (Fig. 1A), menoactivity status (Fig. 1B), OC histology (Fig. 1C), germline BRCA1 mutation status (Fig. 1D), and multivariate analysis interrogating the effect of PRDM1 rs2185379 and the menoactivity status (Fig. 1E).

Subsequently, we performed univariate survival analysis of PRDM1 rs2185379 status as well as of the individual clinicopathological characteristics and presence of pathogenic/likely pathogenic variants in OC predisposition genes. Despite the numerically higher frequency of PRDM1 rs2185379 heterozygotes among long-term survivors (6.4%) compared to short-term survivors (5.1%; p= 0.3), the heterozygosity of the PRDM1 rs2185379 was not associated with survival (Fig. 1A). Of the monitored clinicopathological characteristics, survival was significantly associated with menoactivity status at the age at diagnosis with hazard ratio (HR) 2.49 (95%CI 1.90–3.26; p= 4.14 × 10 ^{- 11} Fig. 1B) in postmenopausal patients. The risk of mortality increased linearly with increasing age at diagnosis (HR = 1.05 per year; 95%CI 1.04–1.07; p= 2 × 10 ^{- 6}), without an apparent cut-off point. Furthermore, patients diagnosed with LG serous or overall non-HG serous OC had significantly better survival compared to HG serous OC (HR = 0.48; 95%CI 0.32–0.71; p= 4 × 10 ^{- 4}; Fig. 1C) and (HR = 0.44; 95%CI 0.32–0.60; p= 1.95 × 10 ^{- 7}), respectively. In addition, we observed better survival in BRCA1 mutation carriers compared to non-carriers (HR = 0.65; 95%CI 0.48–0.87; p= 4.53 × 10 ^{- 3} Fig. 1D) but this advantage gradually decreased, HRs levelled off around 11 years after diagnosis and then the trend reversed.

The multivariate analysis interrogating the effect of PRDM1 rs2185379 with other analysed significant prognostic factors revealed that PRDM1 rs2185379 was marginally associated with worse survival in postmenopausal women with hazard ratio 1.54 (95%CI 1.01–2.38; p= 0.046 Fig. 1E). A similar, but nonsignificant, association of this polymorphism with worse survival was observed in BRCA1 carriers (HR = 2.3; p= 0.07).

4.Discussion

Identification of the genetic and non-genetic factors modulating the prognosis of patients with advanced OC is an important prerequisite for improving the unsatisfactory outcomes of these patients. Here, we analyzed the rs2185379 in the PRDM1 gene in 545 well-characterized advanced OC patients. Recently, Mitamura and colleagues described association of rs2185379 with an excellent OC prognosis and suggested that the PRDM1 polymorphism is involved in the anticancer T-lymphocyte immunity [2]. Contrary to this report that analyzed only a small group of 24 advanced OC patients of the Japanese origin, we found lack of the association between rs2185379 and a long-term survival in our 545 Caucasian OC patients of the Czech origin.

To demonstrate the consistency of our patient population, we analyzed previously described associations of monitored clinicopathological and genetic factors with survival in advanced OC. We observed significant survival advantage in patients diagnosed with advanced OC premenopausally, as described by Chan et al. previously [8]. Accordingly, the increasing age at diagnosis directly correlated with worse survival. Similarly, HG serous OC was associated with significantly worse prognosis compared to LG serous or to non-HG serous OC, as described in previous studies [9]. Furthermore, we observed significantly improved survival in BRCA1-positive OC patients, with the most pronounced effect in the first five years after diagnosis that disappeared after 11 years since diagnosis. Similar results were observed by McLaughlin et al. and Heemskerk-Gerritsen et al, who observed survival benefit for BRCA1- and BRCA2-positive OC patients that disappeared after 10 and 6 years after diagnosis, respectively [10, 11].

Interrogation of significant clinicopathological and genetic factors revealed a worsened survival in a subset of rs2185379 carriers diagnosed with advanced OC postmenopausally, suggesting rather an opposite, if any, effect of this genetic marker on advanced OC prognosis. The PRDM1 gene product BLIMP1 might improve survival and therapeutic response enhancing the transcription of PD-L1 [3]. Blocking PD-1/PD-1L signaling improves anticancer T-cell responses making PRDM1 a promising survival biomarker. However, rs2185379 in PRDM1 does not seem to influence the BLIMP1 function significantly, at least with its impact on survival in patients with advanced OC.